Investment vs fiscal regime in small scale solid mineral mining in west africa

Introduction Small lamina weighty inanimate mining (SSM) in the West African territory of Nigeria and Ghana has been matter to anatomy by sundry writers antecedently to carry out the obscure views akin to the outcomes of taxation and boarding in the activity. However most of these studies are focused on the tome akin outcomes rather than the strategic scenarios of the territory. SSM activity output in Nigeria in 1959 contributed a simple 1% to the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) of the kingdom. By 2010 mining contributed fitting 0.3% to the soundty GDP[1]. This succorary subsidy made by the mining activity to the kingdom’s GDP is attributed to the immense petroleum deposits (African Harvest Bank and the African Union, 2009). In Nigeria the corpogenuine mining law is incorporated in the Federal Minerals and Mining Act of 1999 and the Ministry of Weighty Minerals Development[2] is legal for the omission of all treatment of inanimate media in the kingdom. The Law has been open from the plain manage of regulations set-on-footing from 1903 when mining activity in Nigeria was afloat by the British colonial synod (Ayine, 2011). By the 1940’s the kingdom was one of the tenored remainderrs of coal, columbite and tin. The synod exclusiveness balance SSM in Nigeria came to an end in 1999 when the synod began to dispose-of rightty in mining corporations to privy entrepreneurs. However, it must be renowned that the Law predominant the SSM in Nigeria [3]was not as hard as that of Ghana. Ghana’s fiscal regularity appraises were chiefly fertile for the harvest of the SSM activity on a mean lamina. Though the kingdom too has a sizable sum of oil it did not slight the SSM akin harvests. The fiscal regularity regime in Nigeria of SSM has been illustrative by inquiryers as one-sided, i.e. it is balanceloaded delay petroleum media akin harvests occasion tax concessions to SSM matter, distinctly privy is closely non-extant. Thus this examine analyses the outcomes akin to the possibility developing SSM akin fiscal and boarding frameexertion in Nigeria in similitude to Ghana (The Nigerian Minerals and Mining Act, 2007). 1. Anatomy 1.1. Literature Resentiment Nigeria’s SSM cannot be courteous-behaved-behaved unexpressed delayout a appurtenancy to its continuous slight of the activity as courteous-behaved. For persuasion according to sundry writers on the matter during the 1980’s the kingdom had relied on coal and grove as a fount of fuel for most of the kingdomside population’s day-to-day cooking insufficiencys ( Subsequently coal was sought to be replaced by diesel for the railways though the grassy communities continued to use coal and grove into the foreseeable advenient for their cooking insufficiencys. Fitting 73,000 tons of coal were chattelsed in 1986 as despite a whopping shape of 940,000 tons in 1958. The similar end befell the columbite and tin mining owing by the end of 1980’s haughty track sturdy ore was closely perfectly depleted. The Ministry of Mines and Steel Harvest was fashiond delay a sentiment to developing the weighty inanimate activity in the kingdom ( Though the Minster himself has regularityatic the interpolitical endueors of good-tempered-natured-natured opportunities and incited them to follow and endue in the SSM activity tshort is a public diverge of aversion incompact endueors chiefly due to the ineproperty and doggedness of fiscal regulations to console good-tempered-natured-natured remainder on their boardings (Alison-Madueke, 2009). Fiscal regularity [4]measures uniteed by Nigeria of SSM accept been public to be sparing and innumerous. SSM akin fiscal regularity and boarding appraises in Nigeria accept to be learned despite the Ghanaian harvests in SSM owing the latter has uniteed some of the far reaching substitutes in esteem of the kingdom’s SSM thus hopeful the mean lamina endueors to genuineize and endue in past advantageous areas of the activity (Environmentally and Socially Sustainable Harvest Department, 2006). Nigeria suitable now has one of the most unopen fiscal regularity regimes in the sound continent of SSM occasion on the other agency Ghana has uniteed some deceased features in the manage of taxation. In abstracted to the macroeconomic regularity reforms the kingdom has dispersed uniteed MMS akin regularity reforms in manage to charm boarding to the kingdom. The Inanimate and Mining Law (PNDCL 153) of 1986 [5]vests all suitables of tenure in the Ghanaian synod thus creating one of the most prosperous pillars for serviceable governance of the activity ( Subsequently two addendums were introduced – the Additional Use Tax Law (PNDCL 122) and Minerals (Royalties) Regulations (LI 1349). These laws parallel delay haughtyly open-hearted tax incentives and privileges to outlandish endueors accept served as the cornerstone of the sound SSM in Ghana. But nonetheshort these laws were codified in the Ghana Inside Infollow Act [6]past 2000. By 1994 the resemblingize of urbane tax in the activity was brought down to 35% in Ghana occasion the chief outlay pay to endueors was extensiond to 20% in the primitive year. Subsequently in each year the endueor is entitled to 15% .of pays from 1986. The Royalty blame congenial at 6% of the soundty price of the inanimate was succeedingly unworthy to 3%. All other duties such as tenor calling, inanimate calling and the outlandish substitute tax were chattelsed separeprimand delay. The tenor taxes on machinery and equipment were too exempted ( These harvests fashiond a rallyd cumulative collision on the SSM scenario in Ghana. Tshort was too the supplies to enjoin the leaseholder to hold 25% of the outlandish substitute hues in a outlandish bank soundity. This is intended to facilitate the lapse of equipment and machinery. Ghana’s fiscal regularity appraises on SSM are spacious and divers. For persuasion the net introduce appreciate of the boarding is sought to be maximized for the endueor in specimen delay a similitude on discussable net remainder from opinion boarding vehicles such as purchasing synod or/and urbane bonds, shares and other boardings in capitals ( After tax resign of the boarding matters so abundant that the net introduce appreciate of the posse ought to be maximized distinctly in an SSM environment. Inanimate taxation manages [7]ought to accept into inducement the genuineized useability as despite the virtual and encourage the secure to pay tail chief borrowings at an existing age. Tax duplication must be shirked and any structural commutation initiatives undercharmed by the posse must follow to a prosperous blank delay the succor of the tax manage (Hossain, 2003). Past the SSM activity insist-upons a haughtyer resemblingize of chief boarding for a longer conclusion of occasion antecedently diffuse rallyd hues are made the tax manage of the kingdom must be pointd to accommoage concerns of the endueor. According to some late inquiry exertions tax manages on inanimate interrogation and harvest frequently run into rude weather in occasions of economic recessions owing synods miss to remainder diffuse buffer despite the boarding missure (Economic Commission for Africa, 2004). If the synod misss to maximize the net introduce appreciate of tax infollow and gain past tax infollow during conclusions of haughty use hues by companies, then tshort would be some incapacities hence into the manage to neutralize it from registering rallyd augmentation. Marginally fertile mines accept to be brought into haughtyer resign sunders thrude chief intensive product techniques. Inside consume drivers love synod and inquiry & harvest [8](R&D) must be restrainled in such a behavior to shirk consume rises in product. 1.2. Inquiry Methodology Secondary axioms was attentive thrude an wide inquiry exertion conducted in libraries and online. The knowledge touching SSM was attentive in manage to awaken and follow to blanks. Induced axioms is impart-among as the succor agency axioms or the axioms that accept been unguarded antecedently for sundry discusss. It is not new axioms as the primitive axioms. It is not-absolutely easier to confront succorary axioms than the primitive axioms (Twerefou, 2009). Various founts are used to utensil the extrinsic by using succorary axioms collected from such founts as textbooks, negotiative journals, and sundry university publications, urbane reports of sundry companies and the synod, and university theses. These founts were used to awaken and remainder the received accublame inferences touching the SSM in Nigeria and Ghana. These succorary axioms founts accept remainderd an wide conception of the fiscal regularity appraises uniteed by Nigeria and Ghana (Davis, Ossowski & Fedelino, 2003). The similitude has been made to appearance that Ghanaian manage of taxation [9]is far surpassing in the weighty inanimate mining and interrogation activity when compared to the Nigerian manage.Various textbooks and publications were used to construct and induce received speculative blanks and compel confrontings. References were acceptn from most of the inquiry symbolical profitable in the ground. Speculative anatomy is abundant courteous-behaved-behaved facilitated than primitive symbolical which is basically scant to responses in the topicnaire and the contemplate. Too tshort is immanent thought on the featureize and affinity of vulgar inquiry. Appropriate web sites and negotiative documents links were accessed to remainder past exactness to the examine and for excite appurtenancy (Onugu, 2005).Future inquiry possibilities in the ground are discussed in profoundness to appearance how speculative underpinnings evolve delay occasion and immeasurableness delay inequitable appurtenancy to the vulgar harvests in the SSM ground. 1.3. Circumstantial and inductive agreementnalistic This monograph used circumstantial agreementnalistic as despite inductive agreementnalistic. Circumstantial inquiry refers to a mode in which a past public entrance leads to a past feature entrance. For issue the inquiryer may set-on-foot off delay a plea on the matter and then construct up a train of hypotheses to enter at inequitable details of the inquiry subject (Campbell, 2009). Circumstantial agreementnalistic is casually public as top-down entrance. On the other agency inductive agreementnalistic refers to the antagonistic mode or entrance. In inductive inquiry the inquiryer set-on-foots from past inequitable hypotheses and then go on to publicized areas of examine. This is casually public as bottom-up entrance. 1.4. Inquiry Limitations The activity-centric inquiry regularityology view was focused on twain the necessary and regulative paradigms but at-last the regulative view was hindered by a miscellany of shortcomings including the want of this inquiryer to gain rightty testing appraises. However it must be renowned short that this minute examine would pay past heed to regulative shelves than to necessary axioms shelves caused by an activity in transition (Daniel & Keen, 2010). The skewed species of published axioms cannot be stressed on too abundant either owing such prepossession and prepossession are singly too vile at each resemblingize. However for the point of ascertaining the tax manage akin outcomes such skewed axioms did not accept a main infrequented collision on blanks. Instant the all too courteous-behaved-behaved public limitations, viz. cultural prepossession [10]and prepossession displayed by inquiryers in Nigeria and Ghana agency accept hampered the exertions of this inquiryer to a unequivocal space. By aftercited severe restrain mechanisms and a set of appropriate guidelines the correctness of the anatomy can be made suitable though. This attraction secretly some axioms sets were characterized by a stage of incorrectness delay esteem to anatomy. The late harvests in the SSM were not diffusely borne out by these analyses (MBendi, 2011). Thus the regulative inquiry view too assumes a forcible appraisement of suitable or wickedness. Organizational settings could accept hampered the axioms store exertions of sundry inquiryers and as a outsucceed they agency accept been influenced by cultural attachments and prepossessiones. The most forcible axioms sets for any careful blanks accept been sifted to follow to some blanks that accept a frequented direction on the erudition outcomes of this examine. For persuasion the Nigerian fiscal regularity appraises as fixed on charming outlandish endueors to endue in weighty inanimate mining and interrogation is chiefly influenced by a crave on the sunder of the synod to remainder tenure to topical population (Chamber of Mines Newsletter, 2001). 1.5. Axioms Anatomy Source: Table 2.5.1: Nigeria’s seven strategic weighty inanimates Source: Table 2.5.2: Gold Product in Ghana Source: 1.6. Overall anatomy Tax anatomy delay gist on fiscal regularity in Nigeria insist-upons a manageatic speculative anatomy of the net introduce appreciate. When urbane taxes are considered the secure is entitled to concern outlay conclusion which enables it to extension appreciate of its rightty. According to Modigliani & Miller (1963) the tax privilege allows the secure to subdue the leverage-fixed douceur in the consume associated delay rising the equity chief. Subsequently Miller adventitious point taxes to the equation. An endueor ought to compel an boarding singly when it has a rallyd Net Introduce Appreciate (NPV). Those boardings or devices whose remainder are infrequented must be slighted. The aftercited formula is publicly used to draw the NPV [1]of an boarding or a device. The not-absolutely issue that follows the formula appearances a rallyd NPV resembling to ?123,928.60 at the end of the five year conclusion. Short the opening consume of chief is inconsequent to be 12%. Year Coin glide Discounted coin glide 0= ?-(10,000.00) 1 10,000.00 =? 8,928.57 2 20,000 .00= ? 17,857.14 3 40,000 .00= ? 35,714.28 4 50,000.00=?44,642.85 5 30,000 .00= ? 26,785.71 —————– NPV= ?123,928.60 Thus by uniteing it as the remittance blame for all advenient coin glides one can serviceablely gain the NPV for them. This imparts a few advantages. In the primitive attribute right financial treatment insist-upons a genuineistic opening consume to be set despite chief. Though balance a conclusion of 5 years tshort can be immanent urgency on concern blames, a compatible impart-back of hues would be ensured thrude right coin glide treatment. After all the balance coin glide forecasts are inconsequent to be regular though, in verity they agency dissimilate. The resolution to compel the boarding is fixed on the unmistakable remainder by way of advenient coin glides and it does not accept into soundity the occasion content implicated. For persuasion the endueor has soundtyly disimpart-among DCF regularity owing he probably considers those advenient remainder to be ultimate and real delay esteem to their appreciates. The DCF calculations and the NPV shape of the soundty boarding appearance that the resolution is fairly fittingifiable owing the NPV is resembling to ? 123,928.60 which is a immanent appreciate despite discussable advenient inflationary urgency, i.e. the opening consume of chief. The tenorance of remittanceing advenient coin glides by using these formulas too depends on other contents as courteous-behaved. Discounted coin glides impart-among a genuine paint of the advenient possibilities. Past DCF[2] is what an singular is ready to pay at introduce in manage to accept what he expects to accept in the advenient, it’s a mode of expressing advenient infollow glides in provisions of today’s appreciate. Probably the most tenorant discuss after DCF is the reality that inflation erodes the appreciate of important in occasions to follow, i.e. advenient. Therefore it’s indispensable to compel up for the mislaying. That is why in each succeeding DCF divers by the enumescold of years, a inferior appreciate follows up (Notermans, 2000). The Inside Blame of Give-back (IRR) [3]sets the introduce appreciate of all advenient coin glides of an boarding resembling to cipher. IRR usually holds the boldness that all advenient coin inflows would be reinvested at the inside blame as congenial at introduce. Assuming that tshort are boarding devices delay remainder that exceed the consume of chief or concern, such devices would be carefully considered for boarding. In other language when the IRR is main the boarding is past charmive. However it’s the NPV that every endueor seeks to unite owing it has a short enumescold of disadvantages or flaws. However tshort is inference or evanescence of manageatic occasion thrude hedging. Singular boarding resolutions of occasion evanescence are inevitably focused on the chief identity rules. Convulgar resolutions to tranquillize occasion and celebscold chief identity are dot new in the boarding realm. Sharpe agreement is used to reckon the sum of manageatic occasion: Here the exploit evaluation is fixed on occasion-adjusted appraises. Now the topic “is the impart-back diffuse indemnification for the occasion?” has to be answered by established out the remainder impartn the occasion implicated. The aftercited explanations are used to exertion it out. The Sharpe agreement enables the commutation of remainder on boardings to be real delay esteem to occasion-unimpeded remainder and the stage of subtility of an boarding. Rp = Average impart-back on the portfolio Rf = Average occasion unimpeded blame Sp = Standard failure of portfolio impart-back (entirety occasion). While Sharpe agreement is serviceable in determining adjusted occasion and exploit of a portfolio, tshort are other appraises as courteous-behaved-behaved that accept to be used in manage to state the resemblingize of occasion complimentaryly. Treynor agreement: rp = Average impart-back on the portfolio rf = Average occasion unimpeded blame ?p = Beta of portfolio (disconnected occasion) Treynor agreement is used to appraise remainder that are in abundance of what could accept been made on occasion-unimpeded boarding. For issue Treasury Bills are short occasiony than other subtility-prone rightty. That’s why it’s casually designated reward-to-subtility agreement. It uses manageatic occasion. Thus haughtyer the Treynor agreement, the haughtyer the remainder made on boardings. However it is not love Sharpe agreement which is a appraise of the abundance impart-back and does not succor abundant. Instant tshort is the Jensen’s Alpha, a appraise that reckons the abundance remainder balance the deposit trade outoutlength as chattelsed in the chief asset pricing example (CAPM).[4] CAPM too uses beta as a multiplier to state the soundty appreciate of remainder. Jensen’s Alpha is a occasion adjusted portfolio exploit metric. It’s congenial by using a retirement technique to state the exploit of a impartn portfolio of a balanceseer tested despite a benchmark. On the other agency undisconnected (un-systemic) occasion refers to a occasion natural in a feature activity or trade that falters due to a inequitableally divergent substituteable. Undisconnected occasion[5] (or residual occasion or diversifiable occasion) can be balancefollow by resorting to shelveing of one’s portfolio (Lo, 2005). Past undisconnected occasion is inequitable to a feature trade/activity or trade member, shelveing succors endueors either to subdue occasion or soundtyly discharge out depending on the not-absolute offsetting chattels of short occasiony boardings. Undisconnected occasion indispensablely presupposes the entity of a sanative appraise delayout resorting to hedging which can be ununequivocal for a enumescold of discusss. In the primitive attribute hedging is carried out delay the contrivance of obviating manageatic occasion which occurs as the outsucceed of an exogenous substituteable going wandering. In the occurrence of undisconnected occasion exogenous substituteables are inconsequent to beaccept in the predictable way (Lehmann, 1990). Thus forecasts are received to the sstep that the singular virtual endueor does not impress the insufficiency to derange the basket of boardings. Capital balanceseers whose instincts the endueor relies on, do not impress bound to appoint clients on the incompatible resolutions. In reality such appoint depends not singly the instincts of capital balanceseers but too statistical forecasts. As the portfolio is past diversified undisconnected occasion moves closer to cipher. Accounting occasion[6], financial occasion [7]and economic occasion[8] are all sunder and package of undisconnected occasion. They betoken the very species of occasion. For persuasion a financial occasion agency complicate mistakes in coin glide forecasts thus tenored to liquidity problems. These residual occasions do not accept a big collision on the sound manage. The manageic blank wall stands out as the most trustworthy deposit despite occasion. But at-last the stage of this blank wall is stated by a enumescold of other contents that are natural to the manage itself. Calculations complicate the similar mode as balance. However, CAPM is frequently used to appraise an singular deposit or a portfolio. Additionally the deposit trade outoutlength [9](SML) is used to appraise the reward-to-occasion agreement of a deposit in appurtenancy to the soundty trade as appearancen underneath. Finally soundty occasion is the sum soundty of manageatic occasion and undisconnected occasion. Occasion the valuable of the singular endueor betwixt opposed types of securities or boarding instruments matters short, tshort is the insufficiency for the endueor to compel some real resolutions involving which occasion out of manageatic and undisconnected occasions to be unworthy vis-a-vis the other. The aftercited graph illustrates the not-absolutely scenario of a posse which endues in a impartn portfolio of securities. The red outoutlength is the Deposit Trade Line. the dull axis appearances the betas of all companies in the trade the upright axis appearances the insist-upond blames of impart-back, as a percentage Assuming that the occasion unimpeded blame is 5%, and the balanceall hoard trade allure remainder a blame of impart-back of 12.5% instant year the aftercited would impart-among a clearer paint of capitalamental financial agreement anatomy. The spurious endueor/shareholder/posse has a beta of 1.7. This outsucceed is gained by substituting a few illustration betas into the CAPM equation as follows. Ks = Krf + B (Km – Krf). Table 2.5.3: Beta Values SecurityBeta (It’s a appraise of occasion)Rate of Return ‘Risk Free’0.05.00% Overall Hoard Market1.012.50% Utopia Company1.717.75% Source: This shape and not-absolutely axioms can be applied to recognize all three types of occasions in endueing in the Nigeria’s weighty inanimate mining and interrogation activity. Conclusion Time and frequently it has been argued that Nigeria’s corpogenuine fiscal regularity regime in public and the tax manage in feature touching the SSM insist-upons grave revision to incite twain topical outlandish endueors. It has too been suggested that such a revision or an balancehauling would be exertioned out in specimen delay SSM’s vulgar harvests. Nigeria has been heavily subject on its oil refount and in reality has been slighting weighty inanimate mining activity [1]occasion another West African kingdom Ghana has been manageatically developing its weighty inanimates activity at a compatible step. Thus the anatomy is focused on a separation betwixt activity akin features in Nigeria and Ghana to carry encircling a assurance of the corpogenuine tax anomalies in the prior. While the monograph focuses heed on a miscellany of tax akin shortcomings in Nigeria ranging from the close soundty scantiness of a courteous-behaved-behaved structured urbane tax manage in the weighty inanimate mining activity[2] in public and the SSM sector in feature, it has stressed on the wisdom of fiscal regularity appraises that insist-upon a manageatic exertion sustained balance the years to carry encircling twain a regulative and necessary shelve in the weighty inanimate mining activity. The similitude delay Ghana is made to in manage to sketch a train of rallyd harvests that accept acceptn attribute delayin the Ghanaian taxation manage in the weighty inanimate mining and interrogation sector. Ghana has put in attribute a enumescold of urbane tax incentives and relaxed its rules and regulations on the wages of mining suitables[3] to console the virtual outlandish endueor that net remainder on their boarding in the sector would remainder past than anticipated net remainder. Nigeria fitting insufficiencys this skin of substitute in its tax manage to fashion a train of rallyd synergies. REFERENCES Books African Harvest Bank and the African Union, 2009. Oil and Gas in Africa, New York: Oxford University Press. Campbell, B., 2009. Mining in Africa: Regulation and Development, New York: Pluto Press. Daniel, P. &Keen, M. (Eds), 2010. Charles McPherson (Editor) the Taxation of Petroleum and Minerals: Principles, Problems and Practice, Oxon: Routledge. Notermans, T., 2000. Money, Markets, and the State: Social Democratic Economic Policies past 1918 (Cambridge Studies in Comparative Politics), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Journals Lehmann, B., 1990. ‘Fads, martingales, and trade efficiency’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol .105, pp. 1–28. Lo, A., 2005. ‘Reconciling fertile trades delay behavioral finance: the adaptive trades hypothesis’, Journal of Boarding Consulting, vol.7, pp.21–44. Modigliani, F. & Miller, M. H., 1963). “Corpoblame Infollow Taxes and the Consume of Capital: A Correction”, American Economic Review. Articals Alison-Madueke, D., 2009. Opportunities in Nigeria’s Minerals Sector, Profitable at: <> [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. Ayine, D., 2011. Natural Refount Boarding Resentiment In Developing Countries: Ghana’s Mininng Sector In Perspective, Profitable at: [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. Chamber of Mines Newsletter, 2001. Tanzania Chamber of Mines Newsletter, Profitable at: [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. Davis, J.M., Ossowski, R, & Fedelino, A. (Eds), 2003. ‘Fiscal Regularity Formulation and Implementation in Oil-Producing Countries’, Interpolitical Monetary Fund, Profitable at: <> [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. Economic Commission for Africa, 2004. Harmonization of Mining Policies, Standards, Legislative and Regulatory Frameworks in Southern Africa, Profitable at: [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. Environmentally and Socially Sustainable Harvest Department, 2006, Ghana Kingdom Environmental Analysis, Profitable at: [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. Hossain, S.M., (2003). ‘Taxation and pricing of petroleum products in developing countries: A frameexertion for anatomy delay application to Nigeria’, Interpolitical Monetary Capital Established Paper, Profitable at: [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. Kopinski, D., Undermining mining: the collision of the financial occasion on the inanimate fixed economies of Sub-Saharan Africa, Profitable at: <…/Undermining%20mining.pdf> [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. Lawal, M. A., Constraints to Mean Lamina Mining in Nigeria: Policies and Strategies for Development, Profitable at: [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. Nwete, B.O.N., Inanimate and Petroleum Taxation How Can Tax Allowances PROMOTE Boarding in the Nigerian Petroleum Industry, Profitable at: [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. Onugu, B. A. N., 2005, Mean and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) In Nigeria: Problems and Prospects, Profitable at: [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. The Minerals Commission of Ghana, The Minerals Commission of Ghana, Profitable at: [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. Twerefou, D.K., 2009. Inanimate Exploitation, Environmental Sustawant and Sustainable Harvest in EAC, SADC and ECOWAS Regions, Profitable at: [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. Websites MBendi, 2011. Mining in Nigeria, Profitable at: <> [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. Acts Ministry Of Mines And Steel Development, National Minerals and Metals Policy, Profitable at: [Accessed 03rd May 2011]. The Nigerian Minerals and Mining Act, 2007. Mining In Nigeria, Profitable at: <> [Accessed 03rd May 2011].