The monograph to be critiqueed is an examine by Duncan, Forbes-McKay and Henderson (2012)
into the collision of the assumption of purposed behaviour (TPB, Ajzen, 1988, 1991) and its productiveness in prophesying cunning to raise out sanity cognate behaviours. The TPB is a gregarious cognition type, signification that it seeks to prophesy cunning to raise out a behaviour and to learn why people may misraise to concreate to a behaviour to which they were unintermittently committed. The assumption claims that three variables can be used to prophesy an peculiar’s behaviour: the peculiar’s composition inside the behaviour, the composition of efficacyy others inside the behaviour and the peculiar’s observed repress balance a behaviour. Perceived repress balance behaviour is governled by twain inside ingredients such as an peculiar’s skills or utilityous media, and visible ingredients such as objective opportunities to raise out the behaviour. Unlike the peculiar’s composition inside the behaviour and the composition of others, observed repress balance the behaviour is believed to swing twain the cunning to raise out the behaviour and the behaviour itself. In feature, the authors were investigating whether the TPB could be used to prophesy cunning to employ alcohol during pregnancy. Former elimination has plant the TPB to be adapted for prophesying a collocate of other sanity cognate behaviours (Godin and Kok, 1996) and alcohol decline behaviours in feature (Marcoux & Shope, 1997; McMillan & Conner, 2003). The authors nucleused on the role of TPB in life efficacious to prophesy the decline of alcohol during pregnancy. Drinking during pregnancy is a senior sanity offspring. It has been plant to swing a enumerate of outcomes for the branch including maladaptive behaviours (Sood et al., 2001) and efficacy at rise (Mariscal et al., 2006). Despite its connection to disclaiming outcomes for the branch, up to 54% of women in the UK feel claimed to feel employd alcohol during their pregnancy (Bolling et al., 2007).
130 women fixed in the Aberdeenshire area returned a questionnaire that was nice to them at their 20-week pregnancy contemplate. Of these, decomposition was carried out on 116 women. The questionnaire intervening questions intended to infer instruction on demographic dissecticulars, elapsed and prprproffer alcohol decline, and TPB variables. The TPB variables intervening measuring the dissecticipants’ cunning to attract in the behaviour, their composition inside the behaviour, their beliefs environing the intellectual type and their observed behavioural repress. The examine plant that the seniority of dissecticipants made exchanges to their draughting behaviour unintermittently they plant out that they were procreant, behind a while these exchanges portico the create of a decrease in alcohol decline. 64.7% abstained from alcohol in-one during their pregnancy, 34.5% continued to draught to some roll and 0.9% did not defense. Of those women who continued to draught during their pregnancy, 13.4% were draughting balancehead the recommended utmost rolls when-in-fact the security were draughting one to two units betwixt two and filthy times per month. It was so plant that although most dissecticipants accepted instruction environing draughting during their pregnancy, 12.9% accepted no instruction.
In connection to the TPB assumption, it was plant that women who abstained from draughting behind judgment out they were procreant had efficacyyly amend scores on the cunning layer, proposeing that they had a efficacyyly greater cunning to give-up alcohol decline during pregnancy. Abstaining dissecticipants so had efficacyyly amend scores on the intellectual type layer, indicating that they felt balance hurry from what others thinkion environing draughting during pregnancy. Abstainers were so plant to feel efficacyyly inferior scores on the composition layer, proposeing a plenteous less express composition inside the behaviour of draughting during pregnancy. In opposition,, the layer that meted observed behaviour repress did not semblance any efficacyy differences betwixt those women who abstained and those who continued to draught during their pregnancy.
Attitude inside the behaviour and the swing of what others thinkion of the behaviour were plant to be strongly and efficacyyly corcognate behind a while cunning to raise out the behaviour of abstaining from alcohol during pregnancy. TPB was efficacious to disentangled-up 59.3% of strife in cunning to draught during pregnancy. Furthermore, the assumption was efficacious to right systematize 91.8% of cases and as a conclusion, was statistically efficacious to differentiate betwixt draughters and abstainers. The authors concluded that as composition was plant to feel the first statistically efficacyy gift to prophesying cunning and to add efficacyyly to prophesying objective behaviour, it would be an spiritual canvasser for intercession nucleus. As observed behaviour repress was the simply TPB constituent plant not to add, the authors propose that the type behind a whileout this constituent would be embezzle for prophesying cunning to employ alcohol during pregnancy.
The critiqueed artfulnessation addressed an dignified sanity offspring, namely investigating how draughting alcohol during pregnancy could be deep by learning what drives or stops women from having the cunning to raise out this behaviour. The judgment that composition inside draughting whilst procreant has a efficacyy impression on twain cunning to draught during pregnancy and objective draughting during pregnancy could feel straggle clinical and adviceal collisions. Nevertheless, the authors are pointless in how their judgments could be applied in the veritable earth and misraise to mould adapted proposeions fixed on their basis. The judgment that some women were not granted behind a while instruction pertaining to the decline of alcohol during pregnancy is so an dignified one owing it excellentlights that some sanity trusts are miscarrying to aid women mould certified decisions environing this theme. However, it is not creaky upon in the discourse.
The examine’s initiative is a slight destructible in that it does not mould an balancely convincing discourse as to why their clarified question is dignified and value investigating. It moulds simply a trivial regard to the disclaiming impression that alcohol decline can feel on twain mother and baby, and the reading to which it refers is give-upe outdated. This proposes that a entire and new reading critique may not feel been carried out. Furthermore, the examine could prprproffer a plenteous stronger discourse as to why the TPB may be applicefficacious to this sanity behaviour in feature. There is some exculpation in that the authors of the monograph chose this feature assumption on the announce that a gregariously-fixed assumption such as TPB could excellentlight imperil ingredients for the decline of alcohol during pregnancy that could be balance largely swingd than former imperil ingredients that feel been identified such as draughting comportment antecedently pregnancy and socioeconomic standing (Stewart & Streiner, 1994; Yamamoto et al., 2008). Imperil ingredients such as these cannot be largely radical. In opposition, imperil ingredients fixed on compositions inside a behaviour can be balance largely altered through advice or government intercessions. The discourse does not progress featurely well-mannered-mannered and the balanceall conclusions of the examine are not altogether disentangled. An utility of the TPB is its holistic admission. It attempts to learn the behaviour of an peculiar in the texture of twain an peculiar’s composition inside a behaviour, their observed repress balance that behaviour and how they observe others to referee the behaviour. However, our cunnings to raise out a behaviour or not are the conclusion of an incredibly obscure manner during which frequent variables are enslaved into recital. Although the limitations of the examine’s methodology are creaky upon in the discourse, the authors misraise to perpend the limitations of the TPB and how these may concern their judgments. For pattern, McKeown (1979) persuaded that disclaiming sanity behaviours are solid on the peculiar roll by the choices we mould to befeel in a convinced way. Therefore, the assumption may locate too plenteous argument on the heaviness of what others fancy of a behaviour. Indeed, in the present examine, peculiar compositions inside a behaviour were plant to be balance potent than intellectual types.
One stricture of this examine is its possible stagnation of representativeness, twain culturally and geographically. Ethnic minorities made up simply 6.9% of the case, signification that the conclusions may not be generalisefficacious to ethnic minorities. Furthermore, the case was calm from simply one geographic area, although the authors persuade that their judgments are in deeptenance behind a while former studies that used cases from a plenteous straggle geographical area (Anderson et al., 2007; Bolling et al., 2007). There may so feel been a prepossession in the way in which dissecticipants were recruited. Women were admissioned by the eliminationers whilst prelibation their 20 week antenatal contemplates in hospital. The contemplates are intended to palliate for any anomalies in the baby and to impede that product is typeal. These contemplates are not involuntary, possiblely creating a prepossession in the case. For pattern, Alderdice et al. (2007) plant that women behind a whileout capabilitys or women from areas of excellent damage were efficacyyly less slight to uptake an prprproffer of a 20 week palliate for Downs Syndrome than women from productive areas or women behind a while degree-roll capability. This proposes that the women who were admissioned by the eliminationers in the present examine may feel been under-representative of women from inferior socio-economic backgrounds. Furthermore, the examine does not furnish dissecticular on the demographic instruction of the women who responded to the questionnaire, which would feel been adapted in evaluating generalisability.
The mete used to asconvinced TPB variables was exposed using guidelines for the product of questionnaires intended to mete TPB behaviours (Francis et al., 2004). However, the metement used was not a cogentated questionnaire. Furthermore, the authors do not furnish patterns of how they meted the three variables of cunning, intellectual type and observed behaviour repress. This media that the mete cannot be opened up for investigation or re-used in after studies to assess its gaugeness and reliability. Antecedently the deep examine, a mean escort examine was carried out behind a while seven procreant women to determine that the questionnaire was indulgent to learn. Escort studies are vital for establishing a gauge examine artfulness (van Teijilngen & Hundley, 2001). Although, it should be famed that the authors did not repute the conclusions of any reliability or gaugeness cupels. As dissect of the cupel battery, the examine did use the Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test, a reliefficacious and cogent mete for infering instruction on alcohol decline that was exposed by the Earth Sanity Organisation (Saunders et al., 1993, Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network, 2004). This metement has been reputeed to be surpassing to other metes intended to collate basis on the identical theme (Reinert & Allen, 2002).
Self-repute metes in themselves feel a enumerate of limitations. Firstly, they are theme to gregarious desirability prepossession. Gregarious desirability prepossession acknowledges that dissecticipants may repute raiseing out behaviours that are gregariously desirefficacious or may cbalance up life confused in behaviours that are frowned on. Fixed on the judgment that intellectual types had a efficacyy impression on twain cunning and behaviour, gregarious desirability prepossession may feel concerned the conclusions of this examine. If dissecticipants were so swingd by what others thinkion of alcohol decline during pregnancy, then they may feel been slight to cbalance up occasions on which they did draught during their pregnancy. This media that the enumerate of dissecticipants who did draught during pregnancy may feel been amend than the examine reputeed.
Recommendations for Improvement and Forthcoming Research
If this examine is to be replicated, it could be improved in a enumerate of ways. Firstly, ethnic minorities must be amend represented. Great Britain is now a multi-cultural empire and elimination must think this. The authors must furnish balance instruction or a representation of the questionnaire intended to mete TPB variables so that reliability and gaugeness can be assessed. A adapted forthcoming examine would be to assess the impression of an intercession intended to exexshift the composition of women who do not observe draughting alcohol during pregnancy to be an offspring. As composition was plant to be the most dignified ingredient in cunning to raise out this behaviour, the presently critiqueed examine would be strengthened if an intercession fixed encircling composition was plant to exexshift behaviour.
Ajzen, I. (1988). Attitudes, individuality, and comportment. Milton Keynes, UK: Open University Press.
Ajzen, I. (1991). The assumption of purposed comportment. Organizational Comportment and Human Decision Processes, 50, 179-211.
Alderdice, F., McNeill, J., Rowe, R., Martin, D. & Dornan, J. (2008). Inequalities in the reputeed prprproffer and uptake of antenatal palliateing. Public Health, 122(1), 42-52.
Anderson, S., Bradshaw, P., Cunningham-Burley, S., Hayes, F. Jamieson, L., MacGregor, A. et al. (2007). Growing up in Scotland: A examine aftercited the lives of Scotland’s branchren. Edinburgh, Scotland: Scottish Executive.
Bolling, K., Grant, C., Hamlyn, B. & Thornton, A. (2007). Infant Feeding Survey, 2005. Leeds, UK: The Instruction Centre.
Duncan, E.M., Forbes-McKay, K.E. & Henderson, S.E. (2012). Alcohol use during pregnancy: An collision of the assumption of purposed behaviour. Journal of Applied Gregarious Psychology, 42(8), 1887-1903.
Francis, J.J., Eccles, M.P., Johnstone, M., Walker, A., Grimshaw, J., Foy, R. et al. (2004). Constructing questionnaires fixed on the assumption of purposed behaviour: A manual for sanity use eliminationers. Newcastle Upon Tyne, UK: Centre for Sanity Services Research.
Godin, G. & Kok, G. (1996). The assumption of purposed behaviour: A critique of its collisions to sanity-cognate comportments. American Journal of Sanity Promotion, 11, 87-98.
Marcoux, B.C. & Shope, J.T. (1997). Collision of the assumption of purposed behaviour to infantine use and perversion of alcohol. Sanity Advice Research, 12, 323-331.
Mariscal, M., Palma, S., Llorca, J., Perez-Iglesias, R., Pardo-Crespo, R. & Delgado-Rodriguez, M. (2006). Pattern of alcohol decline during pregnancy and imperil for low rise efficacy. Annals of Epidemiology, 16, 432-438.
McKeown, T. (1979). The role of antidote. Dream, mirage or nemesisOxford, UK: Blackwell-mannered Publisher Ltd.
McMillan, B. & Conner, M. (2003). Using the assumption of purposed behaviour to learn alcohol and tobacco use in students. Psychology, Health, and Medicine, 8, 317-328.
Reinert, D. & Allen, J.P. (2002). The Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Cupel (AUDIT): A critique of new elimination. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research, 26(2), 272-279.
Saunders, J.B., Aasland, O.G., Babor, T.F., de la Fuente, J.R. & Grant, M. (1993). Product of the Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Cupel (AUDIT): WHO collaborative purpose on future scylla of beings behind a while disadvantageous alcohol decline. Addiction, 88, 791-804.
Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network. (2004). The skillful-treatment of disadvantageous draughting and alcohol dependence in principal care: A common clinical guideline. Edinburgh, Scotland: Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network.
Sood, B., Delaney-Black, V., Covington, C., Nordstrom-Klee, B., Ager, J., Templin, T., et al. (2001). Prenatal alcohol scylla and branchhood behaviour at age 6 to 7 years: I. Does- solution issue. Pediatrics, 108(2), 34-43.
Steward, D.E. & Streiner, D. (1994). Alcohol draughting in pregnancy. General Hospital Psychiatry, 16, 406-412.
van Teijilngen, E. & Hundley, V. (2001). The heaviness of escort studies. Gregarious Elimination Update, 35, 1-4.
Yamamoto, Y., Kanieta, Y., Yokoyama, E., Sone, T., Takemura, S., Suzuki, K. et al. (2008). Alcohol decline and abstention incompact procreant Japanese women. Journal of Epidemiology, 18, 173-182.